Topic 5: "Is this a goal or no goal?"

"You Make the Call" Umpire Forum

Week 5: "Is this a goal or no goal?"

  • If you were the umpire in this situation how do you think you would view this play? All discussions must be specific to the situation and not about the umpire(s) or team(s).

  • Is this a goal or no goal?

  • What do you think your gut decision would have been if you were the umpire with no video review?

  • What parameters should be assessed when making the decision?

  • Is the umpire in a good position?

Rules for posting a comment:

  1. Positive comments are welcomed
  2. No mention of any umpire by name
  3. No mention of any team or team personnel by name
  4. Keep comments on task of the situation with the appropriate rule

Click here for USA Field Hockey's Forum Commenting Policy.